Will Carrot and Yamato Become Straw Hats? Exploring Possibilities



Will Carrot and Yamato join the Straw Hats? This is a question that has been on the minds of many One Piece fans. The possibility of new crew members joining Monkey D. Luffy's pirate crew always brings excitement and anticipation, especially when it comes to characters as unique as Carrot and Yamato.

Many fans believe that both Carrot and Yamato have what it takes to be part of the Straw Hat Pirates. After all, they have shown their loyalty, strength, and unique skills throughout their appearances in the manga series. However, whether or not they will actually join Luffy's crew remains unknown.

In this article, we will explore different factors that may determine if Carrot or Yamato will become official members of the Straw Hats or not. We'll delve into character backgrounds, story arcs yet to come in One Piece series , potential alliances with other pirate crews or factions within One Piece World Government system-anything that could hint at what's next for these two characters who are currently hovering on a cusp between joining up with some very famous pirates-or staying put where they are now.
So why wait? Let's dive right into this intriguing topic!

Will Carrot and Yamato Join the Straw Hats?

The anime and manga series "One Piece" has garnered a massive following of fans around the world. One of the most exciting things about watching this show or reading its manga is seeing new characters join Luffy's crew, known as the Straw Hats. Fans are always speculating which character will be next to join their ranks.

In recent years, there have been rumors circulating that two new characters may soon become regular members of the Straw Hat crew: Carrot and Yamato. But are these rumors true? Let's investigate!

Who Are Carrot and Yamato?

Before we dive into whether or not these two characters will join Luffy's crew, let's get to know them a bit better.

Carrot is a member of the Mink Tribe from Zou island, who first appeared in Chapter 805 of One Piece Manga. She has long ears that can move independently like those of a rabbit’s, giving her an exceptional sense of hearing. In battle situations, she transforms into Sulong form at night where her strength increases exponentially due to moonlight.

Yamato is Kaido’s son who recently joined in Wano Arc episode 984 named “My Bible” . He had been impersonating Oden for years now by wearing his clothes & claiming he was him to fight against his father Kaido & Orochi on behalf Oden’s retainers including Kinemon & Momonosuke.

Why Would They Join The Straw Hats?

Now that we know who Carrot and Yamato are let us explore why they could potentially become partofLuffy’screw:

Reasons for Carrots joining

  • Strong bond with Nami: During their time together on Whole Cake Island when Sanji got married against his wish , both started bonding over common love for sweets.
  • Desire To Sail Across The World – Like every mink tribe, Carrot has a strong instinct to travel the world.
  • Loyal & Trustworthy – She supported her tribe and own after they were attacked by Jack and his beast pirates.
  • Combat Capabilities: Her ability to transform into Sulong form when exposed to moonlight grants her monstrous strength increase that will come in handy during battles with powerful foes.

Reasons for Yamato's joining

  • Oden’s Retainer: He sees himself as a follower of Oden's legacy and wants to carry out his dreams which aligns perfectly with Straw hats motto “to pursue their own dreams”.
  • Hates Kaido for what he has done & wants to stop him from doing further damage
    Kaido is considered one of the strongest villains in One Piece series. Yamato hates him because he is trying destroy Wano country ,which Kaido considers as only source for new members for his army, so if given chance he will definitely try stopping him along with Luffy’s crew.

Will They Join?

The million dollar question, will Carrot or Yamato join Straw Hats? Unfortunately there isn't any confirmation yet whether either character would officially join the crew but let us analyse some facts:

Case For Carrot

There are many reasons why fans believe that Carrot might become an official member of the Straw Hat Pirates. In fact, she came very close at the end of Whole Cake Island arc.

Firstly, like all Minks ,Carrots dream is to journey across seas just like Pedro did before her . Secondly she has been shown fitting into roles within straw hat group on multiple occasions such as lookout or assisting Chopper in medical treatment. Lastly future storylines can benefit greatly from having another female character other than Nami .

However it must be noted that while Oda does take fans' opinions about characters into consideration when writing new content but ultimately it's up-to him alone.

Case For Yamato

Yamato is a newer character than Carrot, and it's unclear at this point if he will become a permanent member of the Straw Hat crew or not.

However there are some reasons to believe that Yamato could join the Straw Hats:

  • His desire to become Oden and carry out his dreams aligns perfectly with Luffy’s dream
  • He has already displayed good chemistry with Luffy in the brief interactions they have had.
  • Lastly, having an ally who hates Kaido as much as he does would be beneficial for Luffy's crew


While it may be difficult to determine whether or not Carrot and Yamamoto will officially join the Straw Hat Pirates, fans can still speculate about what might happen in future episodes of "One Piece." Both characters possess unique abilities that could make them valuable members of Luffy's team. Only time will tell what happens next!


Will Carrot become a Straw Hat member in the future?

Carrot is a member of the Mink Tribe and has been traveling with Luffy and his crew since they arrived at Zou. Throughout her journey with them, she has shown incredible loyalty to the Straw Hats and even helped them during their fight against Big Mom. Her dream is to see the world beyond her home island, so it's possible that she might join Luffy's crew as one of their nakama (crewmates) in the future.

However, there hasn't been any confirmation from Oda or an official source about whether Carrot will officially become a member of the Straw Hat Pirates. While some fans speculate that she may take on this role after Jinbei leaves or if another crewmember departs, others believe that Carrot will remain an ally without officially joining.

That said, it wouldn't be out of character for Oda to surprise us with new members joining or leaving the Straw Hats unexpectedly. Only time will tell what fate holds for our favorite bunny mink!

Will Yamato become a member of The Straw Hat Pirates?

Yamato made his first appearance in chapter 983 when he saved Luffy from being captured by Kaido's men on Onigashima Island. Since then he has shown great admiration for Oden Kozuki while revealing his dreams about opening Wano Country's borders to outside countries just like how Oden did.

Whether Yamato would join The straw hat pirates remains uncertain until further notice from Eiichiro Oda himself as this heavily depends on various factors such as him achieving his dream objectives and how much impact he makes on both Wano County arc and overall One Piece story plot development.

In conclusion, we cannot say for certain whether Yamato will eventually be seen joining forces fully alongside Monkey D.Luffy’s gang but we're definitely excited to see more developments unfold over time.

What are the qualifications to become a Straw Hat Pirate member?

To join the Straw Hat Pirates, one must be chosen by Luffy. There is no official process or set of requirements for joining, as each crewmember has joined under different circumstances and with different motivations. In general, though, a person who wishes to join should share Luffy's adventurous spirit and have a dream that they are striving to achieve.

Additionally, potential members should also blend well with the rest of the crew in terms of personality and skills. This means that they should get along with everyone else on board while also bringing something unique to the table.

Overall, becoming a member of The Straw Hat Pirates is less about meeting specific qualifications and more about sharing similar goals while having strong personal characteristics that would make them an asset towards achieving those dreams.

How many members does The Straw Hats have currently?

The current roster for The straw hats pirates consists of nine core members including Monkey D.Luffy (Captain), Roronoa Zoro (First Mate), Nami (Navigator), Usopp (Sniper) , Sanji(Chef) , Tony Tony Chopper(Doctor)/Pet Reindeer , Nico Robin(Archaeologist) Franky(Bartender/ Shipwright ) & Jinbe(Helmsman)

There has been speculation among fans whether or not there will be additional characters joining at some point in the future. But regardless if there will be any new additions going forward anytime soon or later on in future arcs remains uncertain at this time.

Has anyone ever left The straw hat pirates before?

Yes! Throughout their adventures so far there have been several people who've left Luffy's pirate gang behind due various reasons such as their own personal obligations calling them elsewhere which prevented continuing journeying alongside our favorite group

One notable example is when Usopp initially leaves after getting into an argument over leadership issues during events surrounding Enies Lobby arc. Later on, he eventually returns and makes amends with the rest of the crew.

Another example is when Jinbe initially declines Luffy's invitation to join due to his own personal commitments obligations but later on in their journey he does end up becoming a full-fledged member.

Regardless of who stays or leaves, these moments have been emotional turning points for both our heroes and readers alike throughout One Piece story plot development.

Read More

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here