Boiling Whole Potatoes for Potato Salad: How Long Should You Cook Them?



Are you tired of guessing how long to boil whole potatoes for your homemade potato salad? It can be frustrating to have undercooked or overcooked potatoes in your dish. The key is getting the timing just right, and it all starts with knowing exactly how long to boil them.

Boiling potatoes for potato salad seems like a simple task, but there are a few factors that can affect the cooking time. The size and type of potato can make a difference, as well as the altitude at which you are cooking. With so many variables, it's no wonder people struggle with getting it perfect every time.

But don't worry! In this article, we will explore all the details about boiling whole potatoes for potato salad so that next time you make this classic summer side dish; you'll have perfectly cooked spuds every time. Keep reading to find out everything you need to know!

How Long Do You Boil Whole Potatoes for Potato Salad?

Potato salad is a quintessential side dish that everyone loves. It's creamy, tangy, and pairs perfectly with grilled meats or sandwiches. However, making potato salad requires boiling potatoes first, and if you're not careful about the cooking time, the potatoes can turn out either overcooked or undercooked.

In this article, we'll explore how long you should boil whole potatoes for potato salad to get the perfect texture.

Factors Affecting Boiling Time

Before discussing how long it takes to boil whole potatoes for potato salad let's understand some factors that affect boiling time:

  • Type of Potatoes: Different types of potatoes have different starch contents which affects their cooking time.
  • Size of Potatoes: The size and shape of your whole potatoes also impact their boiling duration.
  • Altitude: If you live in high altitude areas like mountains where atmospheric pressure is lower than sea level areas then water boils at a lower temperature which increases the cooking time.
  • Amount of Water: Using too much or too little water while boiling can also affect your results.

Keeping these factors in mind will help ensure that your boiled whole potatoes are cooked perfectly every single time.

Types Of Potatoes Used In Potato Salad

The two most commonly used types are red-skinned and yellow-skinned waxy varieties because they hold up well against getting mushy during mixing with other ingredients. When purchasing these varieties look for smooth skins free from eyes (blemishes) on medium-sized tubers because smaller ones cook faster than larger ones so select same-sized spuds as possible.

How Long Should You Boil Whole Potatoes For Potato Salad?

Now coming onto our main topic: How long should one boil whole potatotes? The answer depends on several variables such as type(s) used but generally varies between 15-25 minutes per pound but the ideal time is around 20 minutes. You should test a potato with a fork or knife to check if it's cooked all the way through before removing from heat.

It is important not to overcook potatoes for your potato salad because they will turn into mush and won't stand up against ingredients like bacon, onions or celery. Undercooked potatoes can also be problematic because they'll be hard and unappetizing.

Tips For Boiling Whole Potatoes

  1. Start with cold water in your pot rather than hot water.
  2. Rinse them off well under cold running water first but don't soak them unless you are planning on making mashed potatoes since soaking removes too much starch.
  3. Cut larger tubers so that each piece cooks evenly.
  4. Be sure to thoroughly dry skins after boiling so that these delicate spuds don't peel during preparation but avoid using paper towels which will stick to their moist surfaces.

These tips can help ensure that your boiled whole potatoes come out perfectly every single time, no matter what type of dish you're preparing.


The perfect texture of boiled whole potatoes for potato salad lies somewhere between undercooked and overcooked- at about 20 minutes per pound if using red-skinned or yellow-skinned waxy varieties which hold up best against getting soft when mixed with other ingredients like eggs, mayo etcetera! Additionally remember: starting off with cold water in your pot, rinsing off any excess dirt beforehand while avoiding soaking (if not making mash), cutting larger pieces so that each cooks evenly and finally drying skins thoroughly after boiling helps achieve optimal results!


How long should I boil whole potatoes for potato salad?

Boiling whole potatoes is an essential first step in making a delicious and well-cooked potato salad. The cooking time usually depends on the size and type of potatoes you are using. However, as a general rule, it takes about 15-20 minutes to boil new or small red-skinned potatoes until they're tender enough for potato salad.

If you're using larger-sized russet or sweet potatoes, it will take around 25-30 minutes to cook them until they are fork-tender. Boil the unpeeled whole potatoes in salted water over high heat till done but still holds their shape. Once boiled, drain the excess water and let them cool before peeling off their skin.

It's best to use a timer while boiling as overcooked or undercooked potatoes can ruin your dish’s flavor and texture.

Can I speed up boiling time by cutting my whole Potatoes into pieces?

Cutting your unpeeled raw vegetables into smaller pieces could indeed reduce boiling time; however this may also cause them to break apart easily when stirred during cooking resulting in mashed potato texture instead of chunky bites that we want for salads..

Therefore it's not recommended if you want intact bite-sized chunks of cooked vegetables that hold up well when mixed with other ingredients. It is better practice to cut after boiling once cooled down just enough where handling them isn't too hot anymore.

Should I add anything else besides salt while boiling my Whole Potatoes?

While adding salt is essential during cooking processes like these as it adds flavor directly rather than later adding seasoning which only sits on top layer., there aren't many other things needed except maybe some herbs like thyme/rosemary sprigs tossed into pot imparting some additional flavors .

However, if you do wish to add more depth try using chicken broth instead of plain water – giving extra umami notes without overpowering the natural taste of potatoes.

How do I know when my Whole Potatoes are cooked?

Potatoes should be done when they can easily be pierced with a fork without much resistance. A better technique to test for doneness is by inserting a knife into one of the whole potatoes, and if it goes through without any resistance or falling apart, your potatoes are ready.

You could also take out one potato with tongs and gently press down on them using finger/utensil. If they're tender but still firm enough to hold their shape well – then you have perfectly cooked whole potatoes ready for your dish!

Can I boil my Potatoes ahead of time?

Yes, you can prepare boiled whole potatoes in advance; this actually helps save time on the day-of-preparation while also ensuring that everything is cool before mixing other ingredients together resulting in crisper textures overall..

You can store boiled unpeeled whole Potatoes in an air-tight container once they've cooled down completely – refrigerated for up to 2-3 days before making salad dish as desired!

Read More

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here